Silent 5! Resident 5 doesnt have zombies anymore and the 4th person view (or is it 2nd person?...?...) sucks!!!! ...But eitherway, u should buy both, yes sir jeje ...uhm...wait a sec...SH5 isn't at stores yet...are u talking 'bout SH:Homecoming?...
Silent hill 5: no more locked camera that gets me on my nerves and no orthopeic controls that make james crash his fat nuts against invisible walls on a wood. Not hard must I say but the fights are really good and the story is interesting and misterious.
Resident evil 5: TONES OF NIGGERS, AN ARYAN MEGALOMANIAC, MONSTRUOUS EYELASHES AND FUNNY COOP... but don't expect epic plot :v
Resident Evil 5 has the benefits of multi-player but overall doesn't carry the Resident Evil name, the little quirks that made RE are lost in the elements of real battle time. Puzzles were lost, that annoyingly awesome-camera angle, crappy AI. But Co-op is fun. Multi-player is kinda cheap once you get Wesker. o-o
Silent Hill 5 just failed overall. It's still good to play if you're an SH fan or just to play it for the heck of it. But that's the game that killed the franchise so just watch out. XD